The tsunami, Twitter and the Zones: Did social media amplify government generated confusion?

(Cross posted from my Northwest Coast Energy News site)

Kitimat, BC and New York City had one thing in common this week, the misuse and use of social media, Twitter and Facebook, that spread both accurate warnings and dangerous misinformation about an impending disaster. In the case of New York and the surrounding area, it was Superstorm Sandy that caused widespread devastation. For Kitimat it was the tsunami warning after the 7.7 earthquake off Haida Gwaii and no damage but a lot of worry for residents.

New York has a population of millions, it is the media centre for the United States, and much of the U.S. Northeast coast is still recovering from the horrendous damage from Superstorm Sandy.
Kitimat has a population of about 8,000 and my home town is off the media radar except when the Enbridge Northern Gateway pipeline issue pops up on the national assignment desks. If the October 27, 2012 tsunami from the Haida Gwaii earthquake did come up Douglas Channel to Kitimat harbour, it was so minimal that any water rise was scarcely noticed.

In one way New York (the state and the city) plus New Jersey and other states were ahead of Kitimat. In the US, there were numerous official sources on Twitter and Facebook, as well as those ubiquitous live TV news conferences with New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg or various state governors.

On October 27, neither Kitimat nor the nearby town of Terrace had any official emergency outlets on social media. In Kitimat, that may change as early as this Monday when District Council considers what happened last Saturday night.

It has been documented that there was no official response from Emergency Management British Columbia (still largely known under its former name Provincial Emergency Program) until an hour after the first earthquake report from the US Geological Survey. Only sometime later did BC’s provincial emergency officials hold a short conference call with reporters. (At the time the BC Liberals were holding a policy convention at Whistler. After the conference call, TV reporters at the convention in Whistler were doing live reports with taped clips of Attorney General Shirley Bond. It should have been easy for Bond and other senior government officials, including Premier Christy Clark–who is plummeting the polls– to hold a live news conference just as US state governors and mayors did later in the week when it came to Superstorm Sandy)

So in that hour of silence from the BC government, one question that has to be raised is: Were the tsunami warnings so completely uncoordinated–at least as far as the public is concerned– that that was one cause of the misinformation and inaccurate information on Twitter and Facebook? Or did confusing information from authorities simply compound and amplify the social media misinformation that was already spreading across British Columbia and around the world?

Here in the northwest, the two area fire chiefs Trent Bossence of Kitimat and John Klie of Terrace have said after the quake that landline phones and some cell phones were out, in some areas up to an hour after the first shock. Klie told CFTK’s Tyler Noble on Open Connection that after the landline phones came back up the Terrace fire department was flooded with calls from people “who wanted it now.” The ability of firefighters to get information was then delayed “because so many people were trying to get through.”

Kitimat has the advantage of being a small town. Emergency services already had scheduled a volunteer recruiting session last Monday night (October 29) for Emergency Social Services–the folks who run, coordinate and work in reception centres during an emergency–so it was easy to turn that meeting into a earthquake/tsunami warning post mortem. (Imagine that happening in New York?)

The most important issue on Saturday night was the false information on both Facebook and Twitter that the Kildala neighbourhood was being evacuated due to the tsunami warning. Other false information on social media indicated that the giant Bechtel work camp at the Rio Tinto Alcan Kitimat Modernization Project was also being evacuated.

As Kitimat’s Emergency Plan Coordinator Bob McLeod told the earthquake post mortem about the information on Facebook and Twitter:

Kitimat Emergency Coordinator Bob McLeod
Kitimat Emergency Coordinator Bob McLeod at the earthquake postmortem Oct. 29, 2012 (Robin Rowland/Northwest Coast Energy News)

“Your aim is to be saving people, and you’re not saving people. There was one case where someone was going around banging on doors in Kildala, telling them to get out. I think it was over when he was in the lockup that night. But this is the type of foolishness that goes on. You have people going on Facebook saying ‘Alcan’s been evacuated. they’re evacuating Kildala.’ I am going to be generous and say it is misinformation… It was a blatant lie. And that does not help.”

 

 

(For those outside Kitimat you can check the town on Google maps) As seen on this screen grab, Kildala is a low lying part of town. The area north of  Highway 37 is higher on a hill. Closer to the ocean at Douglas Channel are the Bechtel/RTA Kitimat Modernization Project work camps.

Map of Kitimat

Walter McFarlane of the Kitimat Daily recounted his experiences at the post mortem. (We were both at Haisla dinner at Kitamaat Village when the quake struck. See my earlier story here and McFarlane’s Kitimat Daily story here).

After driving from the village to the town, McFarlane told the meeting that he stopped at the town viewpoint where “people were telling me they had already been evacuated out of the Kildala neighbourhood, so my first stop after that was the fire department.” The fire hall is about a couple of blocks from the viewpoint, so it was easy to get accurate information from the fire department.

McFarlane continued, “I found the night of the earthquake that no information is just as bad as wrong information. People were calling me on my cell saying why does the Kitimat Daily say we have to evacuate.” That is because the Daily republished a warning from the Pacific Tsunami Warning Centre that “said tsunami warning, evacuation for the north coast. People were saying we’re on the north coast, we got to go.”

I was about fifteen to twenty minutes behind McFarlane in reaching town. (I did not leave Kitamaat Village until after we heard the first tsunami warning.)  As soon as I got to back in cell  range, my cell phone started to beep with saved messages from my TV and radio news clients calling for information. When I got to my home office, my landline was still dead and would be for about another twenty minutes. The only source of information at that point was Google News, Facebook and Twitter.

I saw the initial, and it turns out general, warning from the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center. Soon I was also getting what I hoped was more specific information  on my marine radio from the Canadian Coast Guard Prince Rupert communications station.

But that, too was somewhat confusing. That Coast Guard advisory mentioned various zones, for example, Zone A and Zone B, but there was little specific context and that point I had no idea what Zone A meant. Prince Rupert Coast Guard Radio then went on to say evacuate low lying coastal areas. (transcript below)

With that confusion, and mindful of “when in doubt, leave it out,” I did not mention the zone system in any information I posted on Facebook and Twitter that night. I only retweeted official information or tweets from reporters I knew and trusted (and I did not see any tweeted official information from the province with a link to the page that identifies the official tsunami zones)

From the interview on CFTK, it appears that both the Kitimat and Terrace fire departments were also getting inadequate information.

“We went to our normal place to look EM BC (Emergency Management BC) and there was nothing there,so we went to Plan B to get information and went on from there,” Bossence told Tyler Noble.

Klie said: “We struggle with that every disaster big or small. Social media, I think emergency organizations are trying to tap into more and more. Up north we may be a little behind the eight ball but sure enough Twitter and Facebook information is out there instantly. Looking at Facebook with my son, I saw that they were evacuating whole cities and I knew that was not true. Because of my experience I can filter some of the information, but there is so much information out there that it’s hard to filter what’s real and not real. It’s an area where emergency coordinators have to get into because its the fastest way of getting information out.”

“Once the phone system came back online at the Fire Hall we got a flood of phone calls,” Bossence told CFTK, “it was nonstop and it was people wanting to know. ‘What’s going on? What are we going to do? Are we leaving?’ and they’re giving us ‘This is what is what I’m reading, this is what I’m being texted, on Facebook they’re saying we’re supposed to evacuate’ adding to that we had an individual going around claiming he was a fire department, he was going door to door and telling people to evacuate. That was the added issue we had to deal with. It was definitely misinformation and a sense of urgency that was coming out through the social network (and eventually the media) was big problem for us.”

In Kitimat, I was told about the man going door to door with inaccurate information and as soon as I confirmed it with reliable official sources, I posted that on both Twitter and Facebook, emphasizing there was, at that time, no evacuation order.

But every situation is different. In contrast, in Superstorm Sandy, another story about men going door to door in Williamsburg, a section of Brooklyn  was not true, as can be seen in an article summing problems with Twitter in New York, where Jared Keller of Bloomberg reported

I experienced this firsthand during Hurricane Sandy. After retweeting a message warning about muggers in Williamsburg dressed as Con Ed workers as an experiment, I received two sceptical responses checking the claim within 15 minutes, both from people who work in the media industry and spend a significant amount of time on Twitter. Within an hour, I received a mass text message from friends of mine who aren’t completely plugged into the social Web with the same warning: “I just read a news alert of two separate reports of people posing as coned workers, knocking on people’s door and robbing them at gunpoint in Williamsburg. I just want to pass along the info. Stay safe and maybe don’t answer your door.” Two other friends responded with thanks.

Keller goes on to stay “I know a lot of people, especially on Facebook, who end up believing whatever they see first,” says Kate Gardiner, a social media journalist. “It’s almost impossible to track something back to its point of origin there.”

You can read Keller’s complete article How Truth and Lies Spread on Twitter  here.

See also How to Tweet Responsibly During a Breaking-News Event by Garance Franke-Ruta  a senior editor at The Atlantic

With the earthquake and tsunami warning Saturday night, Twitter misinformation spread internationally. The first hashtag I saw was #bcquake, but as the the tsunami warning gained traction (especially after the warning was extended from BC and Alaska to Washington, Oregon and California and then to Hawaii) the more common hashtag #tsunami became prominent. As people outside BC began tweeting, they began using #Canadaquake and soon #prayforcanada also began to trend. Completely inaccurate information spread on #prayforcanada (believed to have originated in Indonesia) that it was Vancouver, not the north coast that had been hit by the 7.7 magnitude earthquake.

Are you in the Zone?

At this point, one question has to be asked. The spread of information, first the well-intended but wrong, second just rumour and third, the deliberately misleading, has been seen in social media not only during the earthquake and tsunami on the West Coast last weekend, and during Superstorm Sandy on the East Coast but all the way back to the 2004 Christmas tsunami in Southeast Asia.

For the west coast in 2012, however, how much of the problem of misinformation on social media during the earthquake and tsunami warning was the fault of confusing information from the authorities? Just how were people going to interpret such general terms as “north coast” and “low lying areas.”?

From the BC Provincial Emergency Program you have to ask “What is Zone A?” It turns out by checking a day or so later that the province of British Columbia has created Tsunami Identification Zones.

Emergency Management Tsunami Zones
Before October 27, it is likely no one outside of the provincial bureaucracy had ever heard of the provincial tsunami zones. At that time no one in BC, either on Twitter or Facebook or through the media was identifying the BC Tsunami Zones for the public. Later on, the television networks put up maps showing Zones A and B —but that was only good if you had power and were watching the right channel. Kitimat Daily and Terrace Daily posted an official update at 10:42 long after the danger was past explaining the Zone system. It was no good at all if you were listening to news reports on radio or to Prince Rupert Coast Guard Radio on a fishing boat and had no access to the actual maps.

Compounding the confusion is that the US system appears to be very different from the Canadian.

Also the US system has two levels of warning. The Pacific Tsunami Warning Center sends out general warnings but hands over for a more specific warning map from the Alaska -based West Coast and Alaska Pacific Tsunami warning centre. It uses its own system of lettered and numbered zones for the west coast of North America. (See the Oct 27 tsunami advisory here  Note it is a Google maps plugin.)

 

Alaska BC tsunami warning map
Possibly adding to uncertainty for those who sail the coast of British Columbia, is that usually when the Canadian Coast Guard talks about zones on marine radio, it is talking about the fishing zones as defined by the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, which are numbered not lettered 

 

DFO Management areas
Fisheries management zones as defined by the Department of Fisheries and Oceams (DFO)

 

So in case of a tsunami warning, Kitimat is in Zone B for the province of British Columbia and the Provincial Emergency Program and in Zone BZ921 for the West Coast and Alaska Tsunami Warning Centre. For the much more familiar fisheries management areas Kitimat is in Zone 6 (which of course has nothing to do with a tsunami, it’s simply the coastal zone system everyone is familiar with)

Tsunami warning map
Adding to the confusion is the fact that the EM British Columbia map shows Terrace, far inland up the Skeena River is considered in Zone A, along with Prince Rupert for tsunami warnings (if a tsunami was big enough to reach Terrace along the Skeena River valley, then I can only assume that much of the west coast of North America would have already been wiped out).

Tsunami Zone A

 

The Monday Post mortem

Warning brochuresAt the Monday, October 29 post mortem, when McLeod outlined the events of October 27, he began by looking back three weeks, saying, “I have feeling of frustration about a couple of things. October 7, I took 4,000 brochures [How Prepared Are you if Disaster Strikes?] down to the post office to mail out to the residents of Kitimat, They were all delivered by the post office. On Sunday, I had people coming to me and saying what are we supposed to do in the case of an earthquake? It is really, really difficult to get people interested.”

McLeod said that after he felt the earthquake, he went online to check information and then went up to the fire hall, which is Kitimat’s emergency coordination centre. There he met Fire Chief Bossence, his deputy, the RCMP detachment commander Staff Sergeant Steve Corp and representatives from Bechtel and the Rio Tinto Alcan modernization project.

“For the first little while we were going on line trying to get information. The usual method of dissemination getting information it comes from the West coast and Alaska tsunami warning system, then it goes to Victoria, Victoria gives it to the geophysical specialists and they will confirm or deny what ever the information and then it goes to the Provincial Emergency Program and they shoot it out to coastal communities.

“While in this case you’re working with what you find out from different sources and you are trying to determine how reliable these sources are.”

“In our case, for me the first thing you do when you get word of an impending tidal wave [tsunami] action is check the tide. If you’re on a high tide, it’s a different situation than a low tide

“The movie version of a tidal wave is this 50 foot mountain of water roaring along and this is not what is going to happen particularly in Douglas Channel because of the depth. So you are going to see a surge such as we saw in Japan and it will be an increasing surge of water.

“We were told that potentially some sort of surge hitting Langara  [the northern most island in Haida Gwaii) at 9:16, 9:16 came and went and there was no notification of a noticeable surge of water. So were down to a non event and we were on a receding tide.” (See advisory below)

“Misinformation going out is not helpful,” McLeod said. “You’ve got to set up a stream of how you get information out to people and it’s a valid point. The District Website, the Facebook page, something like that can get information out. But again if you lose power where do get it? Text can work even locally with cell phones. if you’re in a dead area with a cell phone, you can still get text”

McLeod then asked the audience, mainly people ranging from their thirties to seventies if they text. Only four or five people put up their hands. “You people are going to be saved, the rest of us…” McLeod quipped.

If a conclusion can be drawn from the earthquake and tsunami warning in the Kitimat region on October 27, it’s not just that in an emergency inaccurate, incomplete or malicious information can spread a the speed of light on social media, it’s worse that incomplete, inadequate and confusing information from the authorities is amplified and distorted by rapid posting on social media. That concept is not new for anyone who has tried the phone chain game where the outcome is often completely different from the start.

If Gardiner is correct when she says “I know a lot of people, especially on Facebook, who end up believing whatever they see first,” the BC government delays made everything worse. People Tweeted the first thing they saw and the first thing people saw came from multiple and often conflicting sources.  Add that to those Tweets that were exaggeration, rumour and lies.

The problem in 2012 it is not one person talking to one person talking to one person, it is a Tweet or Facebook posting that go out to thousands, or millions of people and that’s a lot more dangerous.

McLeod said the post mortem who said emergency services is trying to get more information out to public, but he added. “The unfortunate part is that if you publish it this week, by Christmas no one will remember. If you start throwing it out every week, it becomes like a stop sign at the end of the street. Nobody sees it.”

(Coming next. If Kitimat had to evacuate)

Transcript of Prince Rupert Coast Guard Radio tsunami warning.

Pan pan. Pan pan. This is Prince Rupert Coast Guard Radio, Prince Rupert Coast Guard Radio. Warning for coastal British Columbia issued by Environment Canada on behalf of the British Columbia Provincial Emergency Program at 2057 Pacific Daylight Time Saturday 27 October. Tsunami warning for Zone A, the north coast and Haida Gwaii,Zone B, the central coast and including Bella Coola, Bella Bella and (unintelligible). A tsunami warning has been issued, if you are in a low-lying area coastal area, you are at risk and must move to higher ground or inland now.
Do not return until directed to do so. Closely monitor local radio stations for additional information from local authorities. Please minimize phone use in affected areas, for further information contact the provincial emergency program at website www. papa echo papa period bravo charlie period charlie alpha.Prince Rupert Coast Guard Radio over.

General warning from the Pacific Tsunami Warning Centre

000
WEPA42 PHEB 280341
TIBPAC

TSUNAMI BULLETIN NUMBER 003
PACIFIC TSUNAMI WARNING CENTER/NOAA/NWS
ISSUED AT 0341Z 28 OCT 2012

THIS BULLETIN APPLIES TO AREAS WITHIN AND BORDERING THE PACIFIC
OCEAN AND ADJACENT SEAS…EXCEPT ALASKA…BRITISH COLUMBIA…
WASHINGTON…OREGON AND CALIFORNIA.

… TSUNAMI INFORMATION BULLETIN …

THIS BULLETIN IS FOR INFORMATION ONLY.

THIS BULLETIN IS ISSUED AS ADVICE TO GOVERNMENT AGENCIES. ONLY
NATIONAL AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT AGENCIES HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO MAKE
DECISIONS REGARDING THE OFFICIAL STATE OF ALERT IN THEIR AREA AND
ANY ACTIONS TO BE TAKEN IN RESPONSE.

AN EARTHQUAKE HAS OCCURRED WITH THESE PRELIMINARY PARAMETERS

ORIGIN TIME – 0304Z 28 OCT 2012
COORDINATES – 52.9 NORTH 131.9 WEST
DEPTH – 10 KM
LOCATION – QUEEN CHARLOTTE ISLANDS REGION
MAGNITUDE – 7.7

EVALUATION

NO DESTRUCTIVE WIDESPREAD TSUNAMI THREAT EXISTS BASED ON
HISTORICAL EARTHQUAKE AND TSUNAMI DATA.

HOWEVER – THE WEST COAST/ALASKA TSUNAMI WARNING CENTER HAS
ISSUED A REGIONAL WARNING FOR COASTS LOCATED NEAR THE EARTHQUAKE.
THIS CENTER WILL CONTINUE TO MONITOR THE SITUATION BUT DOES NOT
EXPECT A WIDER THREAT TO OCCUR.

THIS WILL BE THE ONLY BULLETIN ISSUED FOR THIS EVENT UNLESS
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION BECOMES AVAILABLE.

THE WEST COAST/ALASKA TSUNAMI WARNING CENTER WILL ISSUE PRODUCTS
FOR ALASKA…BRITISH COLUMBIA…WASHINGTON…OREGON…CALIFORNIA.

A more specific warning from the West Coast/Alaska Tsunami Warning Centre

 

WEAK51 PAAQ 280334
TSUAK1

BULLETIN
PUBLIC TSUNAMI MESSAGE NUMBER 2
NWS WEST COAST/ALASKA TSUNAMI WARNING CENTER PALMER AK
834 PM PDT SAT OCT 27 2012

THE MAGNITUDE IS UPDATED TO 7.7. THE WARNING ZONE REMAINS THE
SAME.

…THE TSUNAMI WARNING CONTINUES IN EFFECT FOR THE COASTAL
AREAS OF BRITISH COLUMBIA AND ALASKA FROM THE NORTH TIP OF
VANCOUVER ISLAND BRITISH COLUMBIA TO CAPE DECISION
ALASKA/LOCATED 85 MILES SE OF SITKA/…

…THIS MESSAGE IS INFORMATION ONLY FOR COASTAL AREAS OF
CALIFORNIA – OREGON – WASHINGTON AND BRITISH COLUMBIA FROM
THE CALIFORNIA-MEXICO BORDER TO THE NORTH TIP OF VANCOUVER
ISLAND BRITISH COLUMBIA…

…THIS MESSAGE IS INFORMATION ONLY FOR COASTAL AREAS OF
ALASKA FROM CAPE DECISION ALASKA/LOCATED 85 MILES SE OF
SITKA/ TO ATTU ALASKA…

A TSUNAMI WARNING MEANS… ALL COASTAL RESIDENTS IN THE WARNING
AREA WHO ARE NEAR THE BEACH OR IN LOW-LYING REGIONS SHOULD MOVE
IMMEDIATELY INLAND TO HIGHER GROUND AND AWAY FROM ALL HARBORS AND
INLETS INCLUDING THOSE SHELTERED DIRECTLY FROM THE SEA. THOSE
FEELING THE EARTH SHAKE… SEEING UNUSUAL WAVE ACTION… OR THE
WATER LEVEL RISING OR RECEDING MAY HAVE ONLY A FEW MINUTES BEFORE
THE TSUNAMI ARRIVAL AND SHOULD MOVE IMMEDIATELY. HOMES AND
SMALL BUILDINGS ARE NOT DESIGNED TO WITHSTAND TSUNAMI IMPACTS.
DO NOT STAY IN THESE STRUCTURES.

ALL RESIDENTS WITHIN THE WARNED AREA SHOULD BE ALERT FOR
INSTRUCTIONS BROADCAST FROM THEIR LOCAL CIVIL AUTHORITIES.
EARTHQUAKES OF THIS SIZE ARE KNOWN TO GENERATE TSUNAMIS.

AT 804 PM PACIFIC DAYLIGHT TIME ON OCTOBER 27 AN EARTHQUAKE WITH
PRELIMINARY MAGNITUDE 7.7 OCCURRED 25 MILES/40 KM SOUTH OF
SANDSPIT BRITISH COLUMBIA.
EARTHQUAKES OF THIS SIZE ARE KNOWN TO GENERATE TSUNAMIS.
IF A TSUNAMI HAS BEEN GENERATED THE WAVES WILL FIRST REACH
LANGARA ISLAND BRITISH COLUMBIA AT 916 PM PDT ON OCTOBER 27.
ESTIMATED TSUNAMI ARRIVAL TIMES AND MAPS ALONG WITH SAFETY RULES
AND OTHER INFORMATION CAN BE FOUND ON THE WEB SITE
WCATWC.ARH.NOAA.GOV.

TSUNAMIS CAN BE DANGEROUS WAVES THAT ARE NOT SURVIVABLE. WAVE
HEIGHTS ARE AMPLIFIED BY IRREGULAR SHORELINE AND ARE DIFFICULT TO
FORECAST. TSUNAMIS OFTEN APPEAR AS A STRONG SURGE AND MAY BE
PRECEDED BY A RECEDING WATER LEVEL. MARINERS IN WATER DEEPER
THAN 600 FEET SHOULD NOT BE AFFECTED BY A TSUNAMI. WAVE HEIGHTS
WILL INCREASE RAPIDLY AS WATER SHALLOWS. TSUNAMIS ARE A SERIES OF
OCEAN WAVES WHICH CAN BE DANGEROUS FOR SEVERAL HOURS AFTER THE
INITIAL WAVE ARRIVAL. DO NOT RETURN TO EVACUATED AREAS UNTIL AN
ALL CLEAR IS GIVEN BY LOCAL CIVIL AUTHORITIES.

PACIFIC COASTAL REGIONS OUTSIDE CALIFORNIA/ OREGON/ WASHINGTON/
BRITISH COLUMBIA AND ALASKA SHOULD REFER TO THE PACIFIC TSUNAMI
WARNING CENTER MESSAGES FOR INFORMATION ON THIS EVENT AT
PTWC.WEATHER.GOV.

THIS MESSAGE WILL BE UPDATED IN 30 MINUTES OR SOONER IF
THE SITUATION WARRANTS. THE TSUNAMI MESSAGE WILL REMAIN
IN EFFECT UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE. FOR FURTHER INFORMATION STAY TUNED
TO NOAA WEATHER RADIO… YOUR LOCAL TV OR RADIO STATIONS… OR SEE
THE WEB SITE WCATWC.ARH.NOAA.GOV.

$$

Did the media over react to the earthquake and tsunami warning?


There were also numerous Tweets on October 27, accusing the media of over reacting. The Haida Gwaii quake was 7.7 magnitude. Compare that to the Haiti earthquake on January 12, 2010 which was 7.0. The Christ Church, New Zealand earthquake on February 27, 2011 which caused major damage was 6.3 magnitude. So the Haida Gwaii earthquake was a major event. The tsunami warning that eventually reached as far off as Hawaii had to be taken seriously.

Fortunately Haida Gwaii is sparsely populated and there was minimal damage largely because most of the houses and buildings are wood and can absorb some of the shaking from an earthquake.

Given the tsunami damage in Southeast Asia in 2004 and in Japan in 2011, no media organization could ignore the developing story.

If there is justifiable criticism, it is that some media over hyped the story in the beginning, rather acting to reassure the public in a responsible manner. But the media that over hyped the earthquake and tsunami are the kind that would over hype any story. That is generally the result of management listening to “TV doctors” and media consultants who urge over hyping to increase ratings. (It often works). But those who,  quite early in the event, who tweeted that the media was overreacting, were themselves guilty of overrea

Is “Color” the next big social app? And what about photojournalism?

For those who follow  #futureofnews on Twitter, and similar groups, there has been a lot of buzz in the past couple of weeks since the launch  on March 24, of a new (so far Apple only??) app called Color.  It’s called a proximity photo sharing social media app, and allows people close to each  other to share photos.

358-color_1881983a.jpgA combination of photo crowd sourcing and social  networking.

Most of the chatter is among the younger folks who tweet, follow and discuss the future of news, those who are digital natives, the true early adopters,  the indicator of new trends.

So much chatter that I decided to check it out.

While it is available as an Iphone app, the news release says it is available for the Android, but I couldn’t find it in the Android store and the front page of their website says new Android version coming soon.

So without an Android app I could find, I am going to have to go by the buzz.

My first impression at the  Apple App Store was that  was  that creators are  a kind of arrogant bunch.  On the App store and their press releases  it is “Color™  ”  

Really?

 Imagine trademarking the word “color?”  The company is based in Palo Alto, California, so one has to wonder how and why the US Patent and Trademark Office allowed it? I wonder how long that  trademark will last?  The trolls are probably already calling  their lawyers with everyone else not too far  behind.

The news release calls the program

Color™ is a miraculous, free application for iPhones and Android devices that allows people in close proximity to capture and have real-time access to photos, videos, and text simultaneously from multiple smartphones. Color is the best way of sharing an experience without the hassle of passing cameras around, emailing or uploading images and videos online.

And goes on to say

Every photo, video, and text captured by each smartphone through Color is instantly shared with surrounding phones also using Color. There are no attachments, uploading or post-production work required.  For the first time with Multi-lens, you will finally get to see and keep all photos from everyone at a shared moment, including ones that you are actually in.

One tech site has been calling Color™  the “next Twitter.

So back to the future of news. One has to immediately wonder if this yet another nail in the coffin of professional photography?  And what does this do for copyright? Are copyrighted photographs finally  dead and buried?

Well this his how the process  is explained by readwriteweb.com

What Happens to the Content?
There has been confusion about where the content generated by Color goes and how is it shared. Are the photos taken using Color archived? [ Color chief scientist D. J] Patil  [formerly of Linked In] explained that if you participate in a Color group, that content is not only shared in real-time with others in proximity to you, it also appears in the ‘History’ section of the app as an album. You can share albums, photos and videos using Twitter, Facebook, email or SMS.

So far, Color has no search or archiving mechanism on its website. So the only way that people who weren’t at an event are likely to see albums is if they’re been shared via the likes of Twitter and Facebook.

It’s just been a couple of weeks, so who knows?  And with a program being described as “miraculous” that is a lot to live up to.  The company also has $41 million in venture capital and the app (for now) is free, so where’s the return on the VC investment?

As for photojournalism, let’s wait and see.  

The company had its first real time use at a movie premiere.

The big test comes in a couple of days, when the Daily Telegraph uses it to cover the Royal Wedding. The Daily Telegraph and all the other British papers and wire services will have their best shooters covering the wedding, so the color crowd sourcing photo sharing will be a fascinating addition.

A couple of thoughts:

Color™  has been promoting at events like concerts, premieres, tech conferences (of course) and family events.

It’s not the best PR, but it looks like Color™  will enhance the social coverage of breaking news.

What if  Color™  had been available during the G20 disturbances in Toronto? During the G20  everyone had a camera or smart phone camera.  All those pictures of both the black hooded rioters and the subsequent police misconduct could have been shared with the participants, the onlookers, the journalists and probably the police photo units from multiple angles in real time,

Or the more recent student demonstrations in London?

What happens if there are people with Color™  equipped cameras during the next major disaster or a terrorist attack?  Or folks in Syria and Libya are right now downloading Color? 

There will be a lot of amazing photos produced on the breaking event. The pros, however, will still be needed to take the iconic images (that is, of course, it anyone wants to use and pay for them).

The one group that is going to be hit hard by Color™  are the paparazzi, already suffering and seeing their income drop now that everyone has a camera. Imagine the big star walks down the street and instead of being stalked by one pap, fifty cameras shoot and share the images.

Who knows. Stay tuned.

362-g20ancop.jpg

Enhanced by Zemanta

How in world could anyone misquote my Tweet? BUT AFP DID!

If this journalist wonders about the state of the profession (which he loves or thinks he does) and how low it has fallen,  he has to wonder how in the world (to be very, very polite) can anyone with an ounce of  intelligence misquote a tweet, my tweet.  It’s only 140 characters!!!!! And any computer can copy and paste, right??? It should be easy to quote a tweet, right? Wrong!

As an  author, I regularly check myself in Google and to my horror I have found that a misquoted tweet from me has gone around the planet,  thanks to AFP, appearing in newspapers in Canada  and the world (thanks AFP).

So back to the beginning, I was following the debate about Elections Canada, which has the misfortune to enforce an antiquated law meant to promote election fairness across this vast country. Elections Canada reminded Canadians that it was illegal to reveal election results from one time zone to another.

Most of the debate on Twitter was about ordinary citizens doing the revelation by tweeting.  But, of course, the news media around the world are not bound by Canada’s rules and can report the results freely.  We’ve seen this on U.S. television for decades. On the last election night, when I was still working  for CBC, one of my jobs was to note sites and blogs that published the election results and write a story (that of course would not have gone up on the CBC election site until the polls closed in BC).  The first, if I remember correctly, for 2008, was a TV station in Atlanta.

So in the midst of the online debate, at 09:28, April 21, I tweeted

The Elections Canada ban is irrelevant. Watch for tweets from @bbcbreaking, @CNNbrk, @reuters, @AP, @BNO #elxn41 #novotetweet

 But when AFP wrote the story, the wire service moved only the first few words, not the complete quote.

The earliest use after my Tweet that I can find is  the Calgary Herald   and this is how AFP reported it:

Author Robin Rowland, tweeted from Kitimat, British Columbia: “The Elections Canada ban is irrelevant. Watch for tweets.”

which is not only a misquote, but a distortion of what I wrote.  (One also has to wonder why even when the new owners are cutting Post Media to the bone, why the Calgary Herald had to rely on AFP for a Canadian story???)

From there the story appears on Yahoo, (and sites that pick  up a feed from Yahoo), The Age in Australia, The Bangkok Post , Dawn in Pakistan, the MSN tech site,  (and MSN Finance), France 24, Univision,  and Inform.com.   And that’s just what I found on Google. Who knows what papers ran the story and didn’t put it up on their websites?

We’ve all mistakenly misquoted people in our careers, usually due to badly scribbled notes.  There have been cases of cut and past plagiarism (either accidental or deliberate).

But a cut and past misquote of a 140 character tweet?  That can only be described one way:

#FAIL

Update: 2046 PT  The story is still appearing, just showed up in a Google search showing Maxis, a Malaysian telecom has it on a news page.

Update 2   April 24  1345  PT.  The story is showing up in “past 24 hour”  Google searches, now mostly appearing  on aggregation sites.

Enhanced by Zemanta

“Real time” news tweets, the sinking of the Titanic

A couple of days ago, the Nova Scotia Museum in Halifax, which holds most of the  surviving artifacts of the ill-fated RMS Titanic,  recreated the morse code radio distress messages as “real time” Tweets, exact minute by minute, almost a century later.

323-titanic-thumb-450x284-322.jpg
The museum’s idea was certainly an imaginative way of using Twitter in 2011.

The event has three lessons  on the future of news.

First, the Titanic recreation mirrors the way news organizations and individuals  today tweet in real time for breaking news.

Second while  a news organization might have had the idea to do something  similar, using the files in its morgue (that is if the beancounters haven’t discarded the archive or donated it for tax reasons to a local library or  university), it was the museum that created this Twitter event,  That shows again that news organizations are in stiff competition, not only with other news media and the bloggers and social media but with any organization with the imagination to  do something about a news pegged historic event.

Third, this was a great news and social media story that the news media didn’t pick up.  The only story I saw was an advancer from CBC.ca that I saw after the fact and so I missed the tweets.  The reaction to those who know about the Tweets and retweeted or commented to #ns_mma or  #Titanic were very engaged in the real time story.  The media missed this one,.

I am one  of those who has always been fascinated by the Titanic story, going back to the first time I saw A Night to Remember on television as a small child (and for some reason, that I was never able to track down, the Titanic story always made my mother very upset. She was born in 1914, two years after the sinking, so there may have been some sort of connection)

So I went to Twitter and captured the recreation of the sinking of the Titanic. Here are the tweets in reverse chronological order.   Larger versions will pop up on a click)

326-titanic11-thumb-450x583-325.jpg329-titanic10-thumb-450x613-328.jpg
In this sequence, about half way down, the news media becomes aware of the sinking and starts asking the overworked radio operators at Cape Race in Newfoundland for details.

335-titanic8-thumb-450x588-334.jpg332-titanic9-thumb-450x638-331.jpg338-titanic7-thumb-450x670-337.jpg341-titanic6-thumb-450x610-340.jpg344-titanic5-thumb-450x621-343.jpg
347-titanic4-thumb-450x639-346.jpg350-titanic3-thumb-450x645-349.jpg

353-titanic2-thumb-450x626-352.jpg 356-titanic1-thumb-450x582-355.jpgOne last note, During the CBC lockout, I wrote a blog about the Titanic’s musicians and how badly they were treated by the White Star Line,. See  On Contract on RMS Titanic

UPDATE  Jeff Jarvis has written a broadside about the media and business plans,  Hard Economic lesson for news.  I don’t agree with all of what Jarvis says, it is probable that too much of an emphasis on economics is what got the news media in trouble long before the Internet, But Jarvis does say:

网站长标题
寮佃布鏃ユ湡 鍒嗛 妯欓 纾侀张 澶у皬 绋瓙 涓嬭级 瀹屾垚 鐧间綀浜
浠婂ぉ 08:59 2022/09/26 08:59 鍕旷暙 鐚庢埛鍙戝竷缁 [鐚庢埛涓嶉附鍙戝竷缁刔 姣旇禌寮濮,闆舵瘮闆 / 缇界悆闈掓槬 Love All Play [24] [END] [1080p] [绠涓唴宓宂 [2022骞4鏈堢暘]     411.9MB - - - orion321
浠婂ぉ 08:35 2022/09/26 08:35 鍕旷暙 骞绘ū瀛楀箷缁 銆愬够娅诲瓧骞曠祫銆戙7鏈堟柊鐣戙愬偝闋屼箣鐗 浜屼汉鐧界殗 Utawarerumono-Futari no Hakuoro-銆戙14銆戙怋IG5_MP4銆戙1920X1080銆     213.6MB - - - summer1278
浠婂ぉ 08:35 2022/09/26 08:35 鍕旷暙 骞绘ū瀛楀箷缁 銆愬够妯卞瓧骞曠粍銆戙7鏈堟柊鐣戙愪紶棰備箣鐗 浜屼汉鐧界殗 Utawarerumono-Futari no Hakuoro-銆戙14銆戙怗B_MP4銆戙1920X1080銆     213.5MB - - - summer1278
浠婂ぉ 08:24 2022/09/26 08:24 鍕旷暙 骞绘ū瀛楀箷缁 銆愬够娅诲瓧骞曠祫銆戙7鏈堟柊鐣戙愬偝闋屼箣鐗 浜屼汉鐧界殗 Utawarerumono-Futari no Hakuoro-銆戙14銆戙怋IG5_MP4銆戙1280X720銆     107.3MB - - - summer1278
浠婂ぉ 08:18 2022/09/26 08:18 鍕旷暙 骞绘ū瀛楀箷缁 銆愬够妯卞瓧骞曠粍銆戙7鏈堟柊鐣戙愪紶棰備箣鐗 浜屼汉鐧界殗 Utawarerumono-Futari no Hakuoro-銆戙14銆戙怗B_MP4銆戙1280X720銆     107.3MB - - - summer1278
浠婂ぉ 04:01 2022/09/26 04:01 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] Knights of the Zodiac - Saint Seiya S2 - 10 (CR 1920x1080 AVC AAC MKV)     1.3GB 2 1 2 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
浠婂ぉ 02:47 2022/09/26 02:47 婕暙 铡嬬缉鍖呮极鐢昏ˉ妗     3.1GB 1 10 0 keivn36
浠婂ぉ 02:02 2022/09/26 02:02 闆昏叇閬婃埐 GTA III with Ghost town map GTA3 楝煎煄MOD     242.7MB 1 2 0 keivn36
浠婂ぉ 01:56 2022/09/26 01:56 闆昏叇閬婃埐 GTA Mixed 鍦板浘鍚堥泦MOD     4.1GB 0 4 0 keivn36
浠婂ぉ 01:53 2022/09/26 01:53 闆昏叇閬婃埐 GTA3 MOD 缁堟瀬鍐湝 瀹樼綉鐗+178abc6涓汉浼樺寲鐗     2.1GB 0 3 0 keivn36
浠婂ぉ 01:17 2022/09/26 01:17 鐗规敐 [XK SPIRITS][Kamen Rider Geats][04][绠鏃ュ弻璇璢[1080P][WEBrip][MP4]     966.4MB 7 4 26 灏忔绔
浠婂ぉ 01:13 2022/09/26 01:13 鍕旷暙 鐪熼緳浼氭槦闄呮枃浠剁粍 鑾夊彲涓戒笣.褰煎哺鑺辩殑鍚庡潗鍔.澶栨寕绠赌涓.13闆嗗叏.尝测肠辞谤颈蝉.搁别肠辞颈濒.1080辫.痴2     17.9GB 7 18 12 灏忔绔
浠婂ぉ 01:07 2022/09/26 01:07 鍕旷暙 Lilith-Raws [Lilith-Raws] 棰ㄩ兘鍋垫帰 / Fuuto Tantei - 09 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MP4]     572.1MB 50 18 141 lilithraws
浠婂ぉ 00:11 2022/09/26 00:11 鍕旷暙 鍠佃悓濂惰尪灞 銆愬柕钀屽ザ鑼跺眿銆戔槄07鏈堟柊鐣槄[鍗充娇濡傛渚濇棫姝ユ閫艰繎/Soredemo Ayumu wa Yosetekuru][12][1080p][绠鏃ュ弻璇璢[鎷涘嫙缈昏瘧鏍″] 绱1姊濊璜     264.8MB 21 4 40 nekomoekissaten
浠婂ぉ 00:11 2022/09/26 00:11 鍕旷暙 鍠佃悓濂惰尪灞 銆愬柕钀屽ザ鑼跺眿銆戔槄07鏈堟柊鐣槄[鍗充娇濡傛渚濇棫姝ユ閫艰繎/Soredemo Ayumu wa Yosetekuru][12][720p][绠鏃ュ弻璇璢[鎷涘嫙缈昏瘧鏍″] 绱1姊濊璜     125MB 12 2 16 nekomoekissaten
浠婂ぉ 00:01 2022/09/26 00:01 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 椋庨兘渚︽帰 / Fuuto Tantei (Fuuto PI) - 09 (CR 1920x1080 AVC AAC MKV)     1.4GB 5 1 16 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
浠婂ぉ 00:01 2022/09/26 00:01 鍕旷暙 ANi [ANi] Fuuto PI - 棰ㄩ兘鍋垫帰 - 09 [1080P][Baha][WEB-DL][AAC AVC][CHT][MP4]     572.5MB 14 3 55 ANiTorrent
浠婂ぉ 00:01 2022/09/26 00:01 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 棰ㄩ兘鍋垫帰 / Fuuto Tantei (Fuuto PI) - 09 (Baha 1920x1080 AVC AAC MP4) 绱1姊濊璜     572.3MB 22 3 119 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
浠婂ぉ 00:00 2022/09/26 00:00 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 椋庨兘渚︽帰 / Fuuto Tantei (Fuuto PI) - 09 (B-Global 1920x1080 HEVC AAC MKV)     275.5MB 3 2 17 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 23:31 2022/09/25 23:31 鍕旷暙 鍠佃悓濂惰尪灞 銆愬柕钀屽ザ鑼跺眿銆戔槄07鏈堟柊鐣槄[鑾夊彲涓戒笣/Lycoris Recoil][13][1080p][绠绻佸唴灏乚[鎷涘嫙缈昏瘧鏍″] 绱1姊濊璜     364.7MB 35 4 83 nekomoekissaten
鏄ㄥぉ 23:30 2022/09/25 23:30 鍕旷暙 鍠佃悓濂惰尪灞 銆愬柕钀屽ザ鑼跺眿銆戔槄07鏈堟柊鐣槄[鑾夊彲涓戒笣/Lycoris Recoil][12][1080p][绠绻佸唴灏乚[鎷涘嫙缈昏瘧鏍″] 绱1姊濊璜     387.5MB 29 0 41 nekomoekissaten
鏄ㄥぉ 23:29 2022/09/25 23:29 鍕旷暙 鍠佃悓濂惰尪灞 銆愬柕钀屽ザ鑼跺眿銆戔槄07鏈堟柊鐣槄[鑾夊彲楹楃挡/Lycoris Recoil][13][1080p][绻侀珨][鎷涘嫙缈昏鏍″皪] 绱1姊濊璜     355.9MB 32 1 103 nekomoekissaten
鏄ㄥぉ 23:29 2022/09/25 23:29 鍕旷暙 鍠佃悓濂惰尪灞 銆愬柕钀屽ザ鑼跺眿銆戔槄07鏈堟柊鐣槄[鑾夊彲涓戒笣/Lycoris Recoil][13][1080p][绠浣揮[鎷涘嫙缈昏瘧鏍″] 绱1姊濊璜     355.8MB 54 7 118 nekomoekissaten
鏄ㄥぉ 23:29 2022/09/25 23:29 鍕旷暙 鍠佃悓濂惰尪灞 銆愬柕钀屽ザ鑼跺眿銆戔槄07鏈堟柊鐣槄[鑾夊彲楹楃挡/Lycoris Recoil][13][720p][绻侀珨][鎷涘嫙缈昏鏍″皪] 绱2姊濊璜     170MB 20 3 70 nekomoekissaten
鏄ㄥぉ 23:29 2022/09/25 23:29 鍕旷暙 鍠佃悓濂惰尪灞 銆愬柕钀屽ザ鑼跺眿銆戔槄07鏈堟柊鐣槄[鑾夊彲涓戒笣/Lycoris Recoil][13][720p][绠浣揮[鎷涘嫙缈昏瘧鏍″]     169.9MB 14 3 24 nekomoekissaten
鏄ㄥぉ 23:28 2022/09/25 23:28 鍕旷暙 LoliHouse [璞岃眴瀛楀箷缁&LoliHouse] 鐜嬭呭ぉ涓 绗洓瀛 / Kingdom S4 - 25 [WebRip 1080p HEVC-10bit AAC][绠绻佸唴灏佸瓧骞昡 绱1姊濊璜     443.7MB 9 1 39 LoliHouse
鏄ㄥぉ 23:28 2022/09/25 23:28 鍕旷暙 LoliHouse [璞岃眴瀛楀箷缁&LoliHouse] 鐜嬭呭ぉ涓 绗洓瀛 / Kingdom S4 - 24 [WebRip 1080p HEVC-10bit AAC][绠绻佸唴灏佸瓧骞昡 绱1姊濊璜     502.3MB 8 2 32 LoliHouse
鏄ㄥぉ 23:18 2022/09/25 23:18 鍕旷暙 Lilith-Raws [Lilith-Raws] 鐣颁笘鐣岃棩灞 / Isekai Yakkyoku - 12 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MP4]     444.9MB 96 4 406 lilithraws
鏄ㄥぉ 23:08 2022/09/25 23:08 瀛e害鍏ㄩ泦 WBX-SUB [WBX-SUB] 銈广偆銉笺儓銉椼儶銈儱銈⑩櫔/Suite Precure鈾/缁勬洸 鍏変箣缇庡皯濂斥櫔 TV+Movie [BDrip][HEVC 1080P FLAC/AC3][澶栨寕绻佺畝涓棩瀛楀箷] 绱1姊濊璜     52.4GB 5 13 3 Seconder
鏄ㄥぉ 22:51 2022/09/25 22:51 鍕旷暙 鐖辨亱瀛楀箷绀 [鐖辨亱&婕尗瀛楀箷缁刔[7鏈堟柊鐣猐[濂戠害涔嬪惢][Engage Kiss][12][1080P][MP4][GB][绠涓璢     383.3MB 5 3 23 KissSub
鏄ㄥぉ 22:51 2022/09/25 22:51 鍕旷暙 鐖辨亱瀛楀箷绀 [鎰涙垁&婕矒瀛楀箷绲刔[7鏈堟柊鐣猐[濂戠磩涔嬪惢][Engage Kiss][12][1080P][MP4][BIG5][绻佷腑]     383.1MB 9 0 33 KissSub
鏄ㄥぉ 22:09 2022/09/25 22:09 瀛e害鍏ㄩ泦 肠.肠鍔ㄦ极 [c.c鍕曟极][7鏈堟柊鐣猐[Lycoris Recoil / 鑾夊彲楹楃挡][01-13][鍚堥泦][BIG5][1080P][MP4]     3.7GB 96 15 239 lleeopen
鏄ㄥぉ 22:00 2022/09/25 22:00 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 鑺辩伀閰辨绘槸杩熷埌 / Hanabi-chan wa Okuregachi - 12 (CR 1920x1080 AVC AAC MKV)     232.2MB 1 1 21 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 21:59 2022/09/25 21:59 鍕旷暙 璞岃眴瀛楀箷缁 銆愯睂璞嗗瓧骞曠粍銆慬鐜嬭呭ぉ涓 绗洓瀛 / Kingdom_S4][24-25][绠浣揮[1080P][MP4] 绱1姊濊璜     799.8MB 5 1 29 鏄ラ煶鐖辫坛补颈谤补
鏄ㄥぉ 21:59 2022/09/25 21:59 鍕旷暙 璞岃眴瀛楀箷缁 銆愯睂璞嗗瓧骞曠祫銆慬鐜嬭呭ぉ涓 绗洓瀛 / Kingdom_S4][24-25][绻侀珨][1080P][MP4] 绱2姊濊璜     800MB 17 5 91 鏄ラ煶鐖辫坛补颈谤补
鏄ㄥぉ 21:58 2022/09/25 21:58 瀛e害鍏ㄩ泦 肠.肠鍔ㄦ极 摆肠.肠鍕曟极闭摆7链堟柊鐣猐摆濂戠磩涔嬪惢闭摆01-13闭摆鍚堥泦闭摆叠滨骋5闭摆1080笔闭摆惭笔4闭     4.3GB 68 18 212 lleeopen
鏄ㄥぉ 21:31 2022/09/25 21:31 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 鐣颁笘鐣岃棩灞 / Isekai Yakkyoku (Parallel World Pharmacy) - 12 (Baha 1920x1080 AVC AAC MP4) 绱1姊濊璜     445MB 52 7 460 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 21:31 2022/09/25 21:31 鍕旷暙 ANi [ANi] Parallel World Pharmacy - 鐣颁笘鐣岃棩灞 - 12 [1080P][Baha][WEB-DL][AAC AVC][CHT][MP4]     445.4MB 30 2 271 ANiTorrent
鏄ㄥぉ 21:31 2022/09/25 21:31 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 寮備笘鐣岃嵂灞 / Isekai Yakkyoku (Parallel World Pharmacy) - 12 (CR 1920x1080 AVC AAC MKV)     1.3GB 4 1 16 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 21:30 2022/09/25 21:30 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 濂囧够涓栫晫鑽眬 / Isekai Yakkyoku (Parallel World Pharmacy) - 12 (B-Global 1920x1080 HEVC AAC MKV) 绱1姊濊璜     226.7MB 4 1 46 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 21:14 2022/09/25 21:14 瀛e害鍏ㄩ泦 [7鲁ACG] 鍙蹭笂鏈寮哄ぇ榄旂帇杞敓涓烘潙姘慉/鍙蹭笂鏈寮枫伄澶ч瓟鐜嬨佹潙浜篈銇虎鐢熴仚銈 | 01-12 [绠绻佸瓧骞昡 BDrip 1080p x265 FLAC 绱2姊濊璜     9.9GB 3 87 3 c8l
鏄ㄥぉ 21:04 2022/09/25 21:04 鍕旷暙 Lilith-Raws [Lilith-Raws] 鑱洘绌鸿粛鑸┖榄旀硶阔虫▊闅 鍏夎紳榄斿コ / Luminous Witches - 12 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MP4] 绱1姊濊璜     532.2MB 47 10 250 lilithraws
鏄ㄥぉ 21:02 2022/09/25 21:02 鍕旷暙 ANi [ANi] 鑱洘绌鸿粛鑸┖榄旀硶阔虫▊闅 鍏夎紳榄斿コ - 12 [1080P][Baha][WEB-DL][AAC AVC][CHT][MP4]     532.7MB 10 5 60 ANiTorrent
鏄ㄥぉ 21:01 2022/09/25 21:01 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 鑱洘绌鸿粛鑸┖榄旀硶阔虫▊闅 鍏夎紳榄斿コ / Luminous Witches - 12 (Baha 1920x1080 AVC AAC MP4)     532.3MB 18 6 118 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 21:01 2022/09/25 21:01 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 鍏夎緣榄斿コ / Luminous Witches - 12 (Sentai 1920x1080 AVC AAC MKV)     476.8MB 0 1 8 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 21:00 2022/09/25 21:00 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 鑱旂洘绌哄啗鑸┖榄旀硶闊充箰闃 鍏夎緣榄斿コ / Luminous Witches - 12 (B-Global 1920x1080 HEVC AAC MKV)     282.1MB 1 1 11 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 20:48 2022/09/25 20:48 鐗规敐 鍏変箣鍥瓧骞旷粍 摆鍏変箣鍦&鍏変箣褰&澶╂湀闭摆锅囬溃楱庡+妤电嫄闭摆02闭摆閭傞赌匢锛氬皨瀵惰垏鐩滆硦闭摆奥贰叠-顿尝闭摆叠滨骋5绻侀珨涓枃闭摆1080笔闭摆惭笔4闭     747.7MB 4 0 24 瑙掑窛娴╄坛
鏄ㄥぉ 20:46 2022/09/25 20:46 鐗规敐 鍏変箣鍥瓧骞旷粍 摆鍏変箣鍥&鍏変箣褰&澶╂湀闭摆锅囬溃楠戝+鏋佺嫄闭摆02闭摆閭傞赌匢锛氬瀹濅笌鐩楄醇闭摆奥贰叠-顿尝闭摆骋叠绠赌浣扑腑鏂嘳摆1080笔闭摆惭笔4闭     747.8MB 0 5 5 瑙掑窛娴╄坛
鏄ㄥぉ 20:43 2022/09/25 20:43 鍕旷暙 SweetSub [SweetSub][閾冲姩褰煎哺鑺盷[Lycoris Recoil][13][WebRip][1080P][HEVC 10bit][绠绻佸唴灏乚 绱2姊濊璜     422.1MB 27 0 85 SweetSub
鏄ㄥぉ 20:41 2022/09/25 20:41 鍕旷暙 SweetSub [SweetSub][閵冨嫊褰煎哺鑺盷[Lycoris Recoil][13][WebRip][1080P][AVC 8bit][绻侀珨鍏у祵]     367.2MB 7 0 39 SweetSub
鏄ㄥぉ 20:40 2022/09/25 20:40 鍕旷暙 SweetSub [SweetSub][閾冲姩褰煎哺鑺盷[Lycoris Recoil][13][WebRip][1080P][AVC 8bit][绠浣撳唴宓宂     367.2MB 7 1 37 SweetSub
鏄ㄥぉ 20:40 2022/09/25 20:40 鍕旷暙 闆宸ヤ綔瀹(贵尝蝉苍辞飞) [闆宸ヤ綔瀹[Delicious Party Precure/銉囥儶銈枫儯銈广儜銉笺儐銈 銉椼儶銈儱銈[WEBDL][1080p][29][绠绻佸鎸俔(妫绱:鍏変箣缇庡皯濂/Q濞) 绱1姊濊璜     1.4GB 7 3 45 MingHyuk
鏄ㄥぉ 20:38 2022/09/25 20:38 鍕曟极阔虫▊ 澶╀娇鍔ㄦ极璁哄潧 摆220921闭摆缁勯暱濂冲効涓庣収鏂欎笓锻极厂罢铡熷0闆哴罢痴銈儖銉°赌庣祫闀峰銇ㄤ笘瑭变总銆忋偑銉偢銉娿儷銉汇偟銈︺兂銉夈儓銉┿儍銈纺阔虫ソ锛氢纷璩赌鎷挞儙摆贵尝础颁闭     748.5MB 5 1 23 澶╀娇鍔ㄦ极
鏄ㄥぉ 20:37 2022/09/25 20:37 鍏朵粬 钀濊帀绀炬椿鍔ㄥ 摆钀濊帀鍝掕儢娆$湡鐨勪笉瑙佷简锛乚摆绗172链焆摆500笔闭     2.5GB 4 2 38 鎭嬩箣鏄熺鍏
鏄ㄥぉ 20:11 2022/09/25 20:11 鍕曟极阔虫▊ 澶╀娇鍔ㄦ极璁哄潧 摆220921闭摆缁勯暱濂冲効涓庣収鏂欎笓锻极厂罢铡熷0闆哴罢痴銈儖銉°赌庣祫闀峰銇ㄤ笘瑭变总銆忋偑銉偢銉娿儷銉汇偟銈︺兂銉夈儓銉┿儍銈纺阔虫ソ锛氢纷璩赌鎷挞儙摆320碍闭     152.9MB 11 1 38 澶╀娇鍔ㄦ极
鏄ㄥぉ 19:59 2022/09/25 19:59 锛诧肌锛 澶滆幒瀹舵棌 [YYSUB-RAW]Chibi Maruko-chan II 妯辨灏忎父瀛怺1355][2022.09.25][AVC][1080P][FOD]     291.3MB 0 2 5 xiaoxin123
鏄ㄥぉ 19:53 2022/09/25 19:53 鏃ュ妵 榄旀槦瀛楀箷鍥 [MagicStar] 鏃呰鐨勪笁鏄庢不 / 鏃呫仚銈嬨偟銉炽儔銈ゃ儍銉 [WEBDL] [1080p] [AMZN]銆愮敓銆     3.2GB 3 2 7 jackieliiy
鏄ㄥぉ 19:19 2022/09/25 19:19 鏃ュ妵 骞绘湀瀛楀箷缁 銆愬够链堝瓧骞旷粍銆戙赌22骞存棩鍓с赌戙赌愭绁炲厛鐢2銆戙赌02銆戙赌1080笔銆戙赌愪腑鏃ュ弻璇赌     1.2GB 10 2 57 骞绘湀瀛楀箷缁
鏄ㄥぉ 18:34 2022/09/25 18:34 鍕旷暙 澶╂湀鍕曟极&鐧间綀绲 [澶╂湀鎼亱绲刔 姗熷嫊鎴板+楂橀仈 姘存槦鐨勯瓟濂 / Mobile Suit Gundam锛歍he Witch from Mercury - 00 [1080P][绨$箒鏃ュ鎺沒 绱2姊濊璜     193.2MB 14 3 131 Laputa
鏄ㄥぉ 18:33 2022/09/25 18:33 鍕旷暙 骞绘ū瀛楀箷缁 銆愬够妯卞瓧骞曠粍銆戙7鏈堟柊鐣戙愬奖瀹呯浜屽 Shadows House S2銆戙09-11銆戙怋IG5_MP4銆戙1280X720銆 绱1姊濊璜     378.6MB 21 0 133 HYSUB
鏄ㄥぉ 18:33 2022/09/25 18:33 鍕旷暙 骞绘ū瀛楀箷缁 銆愬够妯卞瓧骞曠粍銆戙7鏈堟柊鐣戙愬奖瀹呯浜屽 Shadows House S2銆戙09-11銆戙怗B_MP4銆戙1280X720銆     378.5MB 6 3 45 HYSUB
鏄ㄥぉ 18:28 2022/09/25 18:28 鏃ュ妵 榄旀槦瀛楀箷鍥 [MagicStar] 濡傛灉杩欎唤蹇冩儏绉颁箣涓烘亱鐖扁︺ / 銈傘仐銈傘併亾銇皸鎸併仭銈掓亱銇ㄥ懠銇躲仾銈夆︺ [WEBDL] [1080p]銆愮敓銆     699.8MB 2 0 9 jackieliiy
鏄ㄥぉ 18:17 2022/09/25 18:17 鍕旷暙 妗滈兘瀛楀箷缁 [妗滈兘瀛楀箷缁刔 鍦ㄥ紓涓栫晫杩峰寮鍚庡 / Isekai Meikyuu de Harem o [12][1080p][绠绻佸唴灏乚 绱5姊濊璜     402.5MB 28 1 121 sakurato
鏄ㄥぉ 18:16 2022/09/25 18:16 鍕旷暙 妗滈兘瀛楀箷缁 [妗滈兘瀛楀箷绲刔 鐣颁笘鐣岃糠瀹!鐨勫緦瀹敓娲 / Isekai Meikyuu de Harem o [12][1080p][绻侀珨鍏у祵]     478.3MB 17 4 228 sakurato
鏄ㄥぉ 18:16 2022/09/25 18:16 鍕旷暙 妗滈兘瀛楀箷缁 [妗滈兘瀛楀箷缁刔 鍦ㄥ紓涓栫晫杩峰寮鍚庡 / Isekai Meikyuu de Harem o [12][1080p][绠浣撳唴宓宂     478.4MB 22 2 152 sakurato
鏄ㄥぉ 18:15 2022/09/25 18:15 鍕旷暙 Lilith-Raws [Lilith-Raws] 姗熷嫊鎴板+閶煎綀 姘存槦鐨勯瓟濂 / Mobile Suit Gundam锛歍he Witch from Mercury - OVA [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MP4] 绱1姊濊璜     517.1MB 68 10 581 lilithraws
鏄ㄥぉ 18:14 2022/09/25 18:14 鍕旷暙 澶╂湀鍕曟极&鐧间綀绲 [Skymoon-Raws][One Piece 娴疯硦鐜媇[1034][ViuTV][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MP4+ASS](姝e紡鐗堟湰) 绱1姊濊璜     538.4MB 7 1 65 Laputa
鏄ㄥぉ 18:14 2022/09/25 18:14 鍕旷暙 Lilith-Raws [Lilith-Raws] 鐜嬭呭ぉ涓 / Kingdom S04 - 24 [Baha][WEB-DL][1080p][AVC AAC][CHT][MP4]     488.8MB 18 0 118 lilithraws
鏄ㄥぉ 18:12 2022/09/25 18:12 鍕旷暙 澶╂湀鍕曟极&鐧间綀绲 [Skymoon-Raws][One Piece 娴疯硦鐜媇[1034][ViuTV][WEB-RIP][CHT][SRT][1080p][MKV](鍏堣鐗堟湰)     523MB 2 2 19 Laputa
鏄ㄥぉ 18:02 2022/09/25 18:02 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 姗熷嫊鎴板+閶煎綀 姘存槦鐨勯瓟濂 / Mobile Suit Gundam: The Witch from Mercury - 00 (CR 1920x1080 AVC AAC MKV)     1.3GB 6 2 33 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 18:01 2022/09/25 18:01 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 涓栫晫鏈棩涓庢煷鐘悓琛 / Sekai no Owari ni Shiba Inu to - 32 (B-Global 1920x1080 HEVC AAC MKV) 绱2姊濊璜     13.5MB 5 0 32 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 17:45 2022/09/25 17:45 鏃ュ妵 榄旀槦瀛楀箷鍥 [MagicStar] 杩借釜鑰呮父鎴 / 銉併偋銈ゃ偟銉笺偛銉笺儬 EP03 [WEBDL] [1080p] [AMZN]銆愮敓銆     1.5GB 2 1 6 jackieliiy
鏄ㄥぉ 17:44 2022/09/25 17:44 鏃ュ妵 榄旀槦瀛楀箷鍥 [MagicStar] 杩借釜鑰呮父鎴 / 銉併偋銈ゃ偟銉笺偛銉笺儬 EP02 [WEBDL] [1080p] [AMZN]銆愮敓銆     1.6GB 1 1 8 jackieliiy
鏄ㄥぉ 17:41 2022/09/25 17:41 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 鏈哄姩鎴樺+楂樿揪锛氭按鏄熺殑榄斿コ / Mobile Suit Gundam: The Witch from Mercury - 00 (B-Global 1920x1080 HEVC AAC MKV)     216.6MB 6 2 40 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 17:41 2022/09/25 17:41 瀛e害鍏ㄩ泦 [Love All Play][HEVC][MKV][鑻辫瀛楀箷]     7.3GB 3 3 6 roger
鏄ㄥぉ 17:39 2022/09/25 17:39 瀛e害鍏ㄩ泦 [Shoot! Goal to the Future][HEVC][MKV][鑻辫瀛楀箷]     3.5GB 3 3 1 roger
鏄ㄥぉ 17:31 2022/09/25 17:31 鏃ュ妵 榄旀槦瀛楀箷鍥 [MagicStar] 鍛婂埆鐨勫闈 / 銇曘倛銇倝銇悜銇嗗伌 EP01 [WEBDL] [1080p] [HULU]銆愮敓銆戙愰檮鏃ュ瓧銆     667.9MB 3 1 17 jackieliiy
鏄ㄥぉ 17:30 2022/09/25 17:30 鍕旷暙 NC-Raws [NC-Raws] 鍗氫汉浼犱箣鐏奖蹇嶈呮涓栦唬 / Boruto: Naruto Next Generations - 268 (B-Global 3840x2160 HEVC AAC MKV)     449.5MB 2 0 28 涔濆崄涔濇湐澶
鏄ㄥぉ 17:10 2022/09/25 17:10 鍕旷暙 ANi [ANi] 鏂扮恫鐞冪帇瀛 U-17 涓栫晫鐩 - 08 [1080P][Baha][WEB-DL][AAC AVC][CHT][MP4]     712.6MB 5 1 18 ANiTorrent
鏄ㄥぉ 17:10 2022/09/25 17:10 鍕旷暙 ANi [ANi] 鏂扮恫鐞冪帇瀛 U-17 涓栫晫鐩 - 07 [1080P][Baha][WEB-DL][AAC AVC][CHT][MP4]     658MB 6 0 15 ANiTorrent
灏嶆柤瀹归噺寰堝皬鐨勫収瀹硅珛澶氬姞鐣欐剰锛屽鍗婃槸鎹嗙秮鐥呮瘨鍜屾湪棣殑璩囨簮銆
灏嶆柤瑕栭牷鏂囦欢鎺$敤澹撶府鍖呭舰寮忕櫦浣堢殑锛屼篃璜嬬湅娓呮鍏剁湡瀵︾殑鐩殑锛屽缓璀板爡姹烘姷鍒惰┎椤炰笅杓讹紙缍撻鍛婅ù鎴戝戯紝閫欎簺澶ч兘鏄崋缍佷簡鏈ㄩΜ鐥呮瘨鎴栧唬鍛婅硣鏂欐垨鑰呮槸鍔犱簡瀵嗙⒓鐨勭劇鑹汉澹櫦浣堢殑锛夈
濡傛灉鐧肩従涓婅堪鍟忛锛岃珛鍙婃檪鍚戞垜鍊鑸夊牨
鍕曟极鑺卞湌璩囨簮缍(涓嬬ū链珯)鍙槸涓赌鍊嬬恫绲′氦娴佸钩鍙帮紝鎵赌链夎硣婧愬潎涓嶆槸鐢辨湰绔欎笂杓夋垨鐧兼斁銆傛湰绔欎互鍗虫檪涓婅级鐨勬柟寮忛亱浣滐紝鍕曟极鑺卞湌璩囨簮缍插皪鎵赌链夌暀瑷赌鐨勭湡瀵︽赌с赌佸畬鏁存赌у强绔嬪牬绛夛紝涓嶆渻璨犱笂浠讳綍璨换銆备竴鍒囧収瀹瑰彧灞暀瑷赌钥呭赌嬩汉鎰忚锛屼甫涓崭唬琛ㄦ湰缍茬珯涔嬬珛鍫淬赌傜敤鎴朵笉镍変俊璩村収瀹癸紝涓︽噳镊鍒ゆ柗鍏у涔嬬湡瀵︽赌с赌傛柤链夌枒鍟忕殑鎯呮硜涓嬶紝鐢ㄦ埗镍夌珛鍗冲皨姹傚皥妤剰瑕嬨赌傜敱鏂兼槸鍙楀埌銆屽嵆鏅傜暀瑷赌銆嶉亱浣沧柟寮忔墍闄愬埗锛屾晠涓嶈兘瀹屽叏鐩e疗鎵赌链夊嵆鏅傜暀瑷赌锛岃嫢璁赌钥呯櫦鐝炬湁鐣欒█鍑虹従鍟忛锛岃珛鑱怠鎴戝赌戙赌傛湰绔欐湁娆婃嫆绲曚换浣曚汉澹暀瑷赌鍙婂埅闄ゃ赌佷繚鐣欎换浣旷暀瑷赌銆傚垏鍕挎挵瀵矖瑷赌绌㈣獮銆佽璎椼赌佹覆鏌撹壊鎯呮毚鍔涙垨浜鸿韩鏀绘搳鐨勮█璜栵紝鏁珛镊緥銆傛湰缍茬珯淇濈暀鎵赌链夋瑠鍒┿赌
Processed in 0.003 second(s), 2 queries
Powered by tedmind.com Version: 1.8.1
友情链接:小偷程序  镜像站群

* There is huge growth potential in increasing engagement.
Facebook gets roughly 30 times the engagement of newspaper sites,
Huffington Post’s engagement is also a multiple of newspapers’. If we
are truly community services, then we must rethink our relationship with
the public, becoming more a platform for our communities, and that will
multiply engagement and, with it, audience, traffic, and data. We have
not begun to extend and exploit the full potential of the value news
organizations can have in relationships with their communities: more
people, more value, more engagement equals more value to extract.

The Nova Scotia Museum’s Titanic recreation is one example, as I said, where imagination does create reader/audience engagement.

The news media, however, following tired standard operating procedures and so the news media failed. In this case,. following and reporting on this story would have cost just pennies and increased reader engagement on a news story that has fascinated for 99 years.

RR

Enhanced by Zemanta

Twitter is an amplifier, and that’s revolutionary

It didn’t take long after Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak finally stepped down today for a commentator to dis  the role of social media in the Egyptian revolution.

It  was so fast that it is almost as if the Daily Telegraph’s Will Heaven’s declaration that “twitter had nothing to do with the Egyptian revolution” was ready to go with the column all ready written on his hard drive.

Lastly, it was the real human bravery – standing up to hired, camel-riding thugs – and persistence of the protesters that led up to this moment. New Media, if it played a part, was but the smallest of tools in comparison.

Heaven is apparently echoing Malcolm Gladwell’s early contention that social media has little to do with social change.  In his original column in the New Yorker in September 2010, he used the example of the sit in movement in 1960, in Greensboro, when four young African Americans demanded an end to segregation by simply asking for a cup of coffee at Woolworths.  News of the sit-in spread by word of mouth and by the media of the day, newspapers, television and radio. And as Gladwell correctly points out, the Twitter revolution in Iran, was less important than the Western media initially thought and, so far, appears to be a failure.

Galdwell points out the 1989 Romanian revolution took place before the Internet, but fails to note that the Romanian revolution took place at the end  of the collapse of Communism in the rest of  Eastern Europe, spread again by traditional media, word of mouth,  in person or by phone, by radio (including broadcasts from the BBC and Radio Free Europe) newspapers and television.

The point of both writers, who seem have some sort of bee in their bonnets about new media, is that acknowledging the role of social media in the events in Egypt somehow takes away from previous revolutions or attempted revolutions. 

Huh?  

To use an American example, how does the work of Wael Ghonim  and his friends and colleagues in Egypt take anything away from Paul Revere galloping a horse through Massachusetts yelling the “The British are coming. The British are coming?”

It is clear that the young people in Egypt were able to organize themselves through Facebook, Twitter, text messaging. More important they were able to stay organized, even when the Egyptian government shut down the Internet. We will probably hear a lot more in the coming days of how that remarkable scene in Tahrir Square was kept alive through social media.

 If the technology had existed  on April 19, 1775,  Paul Revere, a prominent and well off silver smith, would have had the money to have the latest smart phone and would have used Tweetdeck to send that “The British are coming” to update his status on Twitter, Facebook and Linked In. That status update would have immediately retweeted and the status updates shared faster than the time it actually took Revere to saddle his horse.

By coincidence I have been reading  Stacy Schiff’s biography of the Egyptian queen Cleopatra.  When Julius Caesar and his legions landed in Alexandria in October 48 BCE, the people of the city rioted.  The reasons were complex, resistance against an invader mixed up with the supporters of the various factions, supporting Cleopatra or her brother Ptolemy XIII.

According to Schiff, at the height  of the crisis between December 48 BCE and Caesar’s final victory in March 47,  Rome heard nothing from Caesar.  It is not clear from the book why or how there was no communication, since even at that time,  large sail-driven freighters regularly carried grain from Egypt,then the breadbasket of the Mediterranean, to Rome.  One other reason for unrest that year was that the Nile flood was disasterously low and the harvest had failed.  That meant few, if any, shipments of grain to Rome. As well the December-March period is not the best for sailing between Alexandria and Rome.  But some merchant ships probably reached Rome. Any news they carried would have been rumours. It is likely that since in the beginning, things weren’t going well, Caesar was besieged in the royal palace by the citizens of Alexandria, that he couldn’t (or didn’t want to) get the news out. Compare that with getting the news out of Egypt today, even when Mubarak tried to cut off communications.

Even a century ago, with the steamship and the telegraph, that news would have gotten out.  Even if a city was under siege, there would still be a way for a journalist or diplomat to get to a telegraph or cable head. Accounts of nineteenth century correspondents are full of  harrowing tales of going hundreds of kilometres to get that telegraph point.

On  Sunday night, half a world away from Tahrir Square,  the Superbowl was in its final moments, the Pittsburgh Steelers  were desperately trying to gain the lead from the Green Bay Packers, when  the power in Kitimat failed.  No lights, no TV.   Just a few years ago, for the people  of Kitimat, it would have meant  scrambling to find a battery powered radio (or as one guy did, going out in the snow to turn on his car radio).  As for me, I just launched Tweetdeck on my Android and within a minute or so there were a dozen tweets giving the final score Packers 31, Steelers 25.

The power was out for three hours, on for an hour and half, then out again for almost seven hours overnight.

The game over, the house dark, (luckily dinner was ready),  Tweetdeck was active on my Android, so updates from Tahrir Square came up every few minutes.  That is the difference, that is key. In the past,  from the time of  Caesar to the American Revolution, you would have had to wait until a sail-driven ship arrived with the news.  After the telegraph, most people would have had to wait until the morning newspaper came out.  Beginning in the late 1920s and even  today, news would come through the radio (television is irrelevant during a power failure).  Even the Internet was not a factor,  even with two laptops with battery power, the router is powered by a plug in the wall.

Now with a smart phone, I could still keep up with  events around the world.  So someone tweets from Tahrir Square, someone else retweets it, a news organization picks up that tweet, and sitting in a darkened town thousands of kilometres away, I get that news.

I was tweeting the blackout, which resulted, the next morning, my former colleagues at CBC Radio calling me  in my dark, cold (no heat) house for an update that they could air to CBC listeners.

Technology is a tool, and a tool can be used by anyone. So the critics who say an authoritarian government can try to use social  media for propaganda and the secret police can use it to track down dissidents are correct. A  desperate government, like Egypt, can try to cut off the Internet and world telecommunications, but that will likely fail.  In today’s wired world, with a myriad of sources and providers, and millions of tech savvy users, it is less likely that all communications will be entirely shut down. In the old movies, you see someone climbing at telegraph pole to cut the only line to the outside world.  Today there are not only cell phones, but good old land lines that were used for good old dial up  connections.  Then there are satellite phones and who knows what’s coming next.

US President Barack Obama just said the Egyptian revolution happened at “blinding speed.”  That’s what social media does, it accelerates and amplifies events.  So Malcolm Gladwell, yes, there have been revolutions and protests since the dawn of civilization, but social media is the game changer,  it’s the difference between earphones from an MP3 players and a giant amplifier that fills a stadium  or city square with sound.   To use an old tech analogy,  the trumpet sounds, and thanks to Twitter and Facebook that fanfare is head around the world in real  time.

UPDATE

There has been a growing debate on the role of social media and what happened in Egypt. 
Skeptics vs what they call cyber utopnians.
Jay Rosen of   New York University, a participant in the debate, has created  a curated summary. with lots of links

The “Twitter Can’t Topple Dictators” article
 

Enhanced by Zemanta